Antigua or Barbados - which island is more exclusive?

I'm having a bit of a debate with some one about this. I know which Caribbean island I consider to be the more exclusive out of the two in terms of celebrities visiting, expensive to stay there, etc but I'd just like to know if my own opinion is confirmed.

I do know that there are far more exclusive Caribbean islands like St Barts, the Caymnas, Bahamas, turks and Caicos, etc but I just wanted to know specifically about your opinions on Anitgua or Barbados.
thanks!!
Antigua or Barbados - which island is more exclusive?
Antigua is much more exclusive and expensive to visit. I have been to both.
Antigua or Barbados - which island is more exclusive?
Antiqua if your looking for something a little more quiet. alot less american and British tourists than barbados more ethinic and natural
Antiqua if your looking for something a little more quiet. alot less american and British tourists than barbados more ethinic and natural
Antigua hands down.
By far Antigua is the most exclusive. It offers many options such as day trips to Montserrat.
Well I've never been to Antigua, but Barbados has a very wealthy area with hotels that are strictly for those with money. Tiger Woods got married at Barbados' Sandy Lane Hotel. Simon Cowell (American Idol) is spotted there on occassion for holiday. Mariah Carey has spent New Years there.numerous musicians visit for both holiday as well as performances (check Barbados during Jazz Festival). The exchange rate in Barbados would also make for an expensive trip.